UserReviewexpand_more
A Disappointing Read - Roman Left Me Shaken, But Not in a Good Way
jeremyC_
Books•
2.0
photo_library12
visibility6
The Man-Combination by Sayaka Murata
Productstar 2.0

The Man-Combination by Sayaka Murata

This Japanese novel is a real mind-bender. It's all about the weird and wonderful world of human relationships - the expectations, the disappointments, and the awkward moments. Sayaka Murata takes you on a wild ride that'll leave you questioning everything and challenging your perspectives. It's not always easy to read, but trust me, it's worth it.
chevron_right

A Disappointing Read - Roman Left Me Shaken, But Not in a Good Way

summarizeEditor's Summary

I gotta say, I'm still trying to process my thoughts on this Japanese novel by Sayaka Murata. The Strange Library is a slim volume that's captured the hearts of many and won some prestigious awards, but unfortunately, it left me feeling unsettled. The main character, a 36-year-old woman who's spent 18 years working at a convenience store, is a total enigma - I never really connected with her. The plot's a wild ride of emotions, but it's not a game changer in my book. It's worth noting that the book's short length is a major advantage, making it a great choice for readers with limited time. However, the lack of character development is a total letdown. To be honest, I was expecting more depth from the characters, especially the main one. The writing style is atmospheric and engaging, but it can be overly descriptive at times, which might not be to everyone's taste. Overall, it's a thought-provoking read, but it didn't quite live up to my expectations.

Review image 1
Review image 2
Review image 3
Review image 4
Review image 5
Review image 6
Review image 7
Review image 8
Review image 9
Review image 10
Review image 11
Review image 12

settingsSpecifications

Dil6/10
Kararİyi
Atmosfer9/10
İçerik8/10
Dramatiklik7/10
HikayeKalitesi7/10
KarakterGeliştirme8/10
I'm still trying to process my thoughts on this book, and I'm not sure if I actually enjoyed it or not.
It's been a wild ride of emotions, to say the least - a rollercoaster of feelings that left me feeling unsettled.
This Japanese novel by Sayaka Murata has been making waves, and I'm guessing there's hardly anyone who hasn't heard of it.
The Strange Library is a slim volume that's captured the hearts of many and won some prestigious awards.
The Plot
Meet a 36-year-old woman who's spent 18 years working at a convenience store, doing the bare minimum with no ambitions or plans for the future.
She's content with her life, but it's clear that she's just going through the motions - following a script without any real passion or drive.
I have to admit, I've never really questioned why I chose this kind of work over a steady office job.
Maybe it's because, by following the script to the letter, I managed to become a model convenience store worker, but I had no idea what it took to be a regular person, living life outside the rules.
Everything changes when a new coworker joins the store, and suddenly our protagonist is forced to confront her own life choices.
The Characters
K - it's never explicitly stated, but it's clear that this woman has some form of autism.
She struggles to recognize emotions, can't quite grasp social cues, and even mimics the mannerisms and speech of those around her.
I find myself adopting the speech patterns and intonations of those around me.
Right now, I'm speaking a mix of Izumi-san and Sugawara's dialects.
She's unable to form cause-and-effect relationships and can only do what she's been told to do.
S - the complete opposite of our protagonist.
He's in his mid-30s, but he can't stay in one job for too long.
This guy with a crown thinks working is beneath him.
The Author's Style
It's easy to read, almost too easy.
I finished the book in a couple of hours without breaking a sweat.
My only questions are for the translator - why leave some Japanese words untranslated?
It just adds to the frustration of trying to read them in Roman script.
The Atmosphere
The store's atmosphere is vividly described - the entrance bell, onigiri, bento, newspapers, sales, product of the day, uniform, and the sales staff's scripted phrases.
I really felt like I was stepping into the protagonist's tiny apartment, with every detail vividly painted in my mind.
Drama
The drama in the story ebbs and flows, but I wanted more action-packed moments.
To be honest, it wasn't until the last third of the book that things started to happen, and before that, it was all introspection from the protagonist.
Main Idea
From what I gathered (and maybe I'm wrong), the author was trying to convey the issue of social norms.
The protagonist lives her life on her own terms, but those around her keep questioning her choices: when will she get married, have kids, find a good job, and so on.
It's like, who are they to dictate how someone else should live their life in today's world?
But that's when I started to get confused about the author's message.
If we're looking at it from the perspective of people invading her personal space, I get it.
But the issue is that it's her close family members who are pressuring her, not strangers.
She doesn't even interact with people outside of her family, so it's hard to understand why they're so invested in her life.
Why do 'normal' people feel entitled to pry into someone else's life and question their normalcy?
It's her family who's worried about her, who's trying to get her to conform to societal expectations.
And it's not like she's doing anything wrong – she's just living her life the way she wants to.
Maybe she's just not interested in trying anything else or exploring other options.
Plot Twist
To be honest, I didn't find the plot twist all that surprising.
It was all a bit predictable, and I didn't feel like I was on the edge of my seat, eager to find out what happened next.
Impressions and Conclusion
There were a few times when I was tempted to put the book down, but I stuck with it because I wanted to see it through.
It's a short story that can be read in about 2-3 hours, and it does have a plot and some interesting themes.
The writing is easy to follow, but the characters... well, they're a different story.
I have to admit that I found the characters' behavior and interactions to be quite unsettling.
In real life, we all know people like the protagonist and her family members – people who are a bit too invested in other people's lives.
But in this book, the author takes it to an extreme, making the characters' behavior feel almost caricatured.
One thing that bothered me was the lack of character development.
We only really get to know two main characters, and I wanted to know more about what was going on in their heads.
Were they struggling with some kind of trauma or mental health issue?
Was there something more complex at play?
Thanks for reading my review, and I hope you enjoy the book!
Just a heads up: my opinion might not match yours, and that's totally okay.
I wish you a wonderful day and some amazing books to read!

live_helpFeatured FAQ

Is The Strange Library a good choice for readers who prefer character-driven fiction?

No, unfortunately not. While the main character is an enigma, her lack of development makes it hard to connect with her on a deeper level.

What are the book's themes and messages?

The book explores themes of social isolation, conformity, and the human condition. It's a thought-provoking read, but not particularly original.

Is The Strange Library a quick and easy read?

Yes, the book is short and concise, making it a great choice for readers with limited time. However, the lack of character development and predictable plot twists may make it feel a bit rushed and incomplete.

What awards has The Strange Library won?

Unfortunately, I couldn't find any information on the book's awards. However, it's clear that it's a notable work of literary fiction.

Is The Strange Library a good choice for readers who prefer plot-driven fiction?

Maybe. The book's plot is a wild ride of emotions, but it's not particularly original or surprising. Readers who enjoy a good twist or turn may find it engaging, but others may find it predictable.

What's the book's tone and atmosphere like?

The book's tone is atmospheric and engaging, with a unique narrative voice. However, it can be overly descriptive at times, which may be a turn-off for some readers.

Is The Strange Library a good choice for readers who prefer books with complex characters?

No, unfortunately not. The characters are underdeveloped and lack depth, making it hard to connect with them on a deeper level.

What's the book's message about social isolation and conformity?

The book explores the themes of social isolation and conformity in a thought-provoking way. However, it's not particularly original or surprising, and readers may find it a bit heavy-handed at times.

How does the book's writing style contribute to its atmosphere?

The writing style is engaging and immersive, but it can be overly descriptive at times, which might not be to everyone's taste.

What are some potential drawbacks to reading The Strange Library?

The book's lack of character development and predictable plot twists may make it feel a bit rushed and incomplete. Additionally, the writing style can be overly descriptive at times.

check_circlePros

  • •Atmospheric and engaging, with a unique narrative voice
  • •Short and concise, making it a great choice for readers with limited time
  • •Won prestigious awards, so it's definitely a notable work of literary fiction
  • •The plot's a wild ride of emotions, keeping readers on their toes
  • •The main character's enigmatic nature adds to the book's mystique
  • •The book's themes of social isolation and conformity are thought-provoking
  • •The writing style is engaging and immersive
  • •The book's exploration of the human condition is thought-provoking

cancelCons

  • •The characters are underdeveloped and lack depth
  • •I never really connected with the main character, which made it hard to care about her journey
  • •The book's themes, while thought-provoking, are not particularly original
  • •The plot's twists and turns are predictable and lack surprise
  • •The book's short length makes it feel a bit rushed and incomplete
  • •The writing style, while atmospheric, can be overly descriptive at times
  • •The main character's lack of development makes it hard to relate to her
  • •The book's message about social isolation and conformity feels a bit heavy-handed
chat_bubble
flag

Related Reviews

More reviews in Books.

View all reviews
A Bittersweet Tale of Self-Discovery
Portrait of bykopiluwak
bykopiluwak• last week

A Bittersweet Tale of Self-Discovery

Catch-22 is a thought-provoking novel by Joseph Heller that tells the story of Charlie Gordon, a 33-year-old janitor with some developmental issues, as he navig

Books / Literary Fiction
thumb_up0
chat_bubble0
A Book That Really Works Its Magic
Portrait of bykopiluwak
bykopiluwak• last week

A Book That Really Works Its Magic

Discover the magic of this book and unlock your full potential with its powerful meditation techniques and personal development strategies.

Other Books
thumb_up0
chat_bubble0

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!