I revisited Mortel Transfert a few times and decided it was time to write a review. When I looked it up online, I was surprised to find it's not super well-known. I couldn't even find any mention of it on IMDB.
Other films by the director are more popular: Diva, Luna in the Sewer, and so on. But the storylines of those films didn't really grab me, whereas Mortel Transfert seemed really intriguing, and I'm glad I took a chance on it.
The title of the film is attention-grabbing, but it doesn't quite capture the essence of the original. It's not about corpses at all – it's about transference, where a patient projects their feelings onto their therapist and vice versa.
The original title is much more concise and accurately reflects the film's themes. The translated title, on the other hand, is a bit of a joke and plays on the idea of 'transferring' corpses.
==========================================
Where the film starts:
Michel Duran is a successful psychoanalyst with his own office, a housekeeper, and a regular client base. Sessions go by one after another, but when he's working with neurotic kleptomaniac Olga Kubler, he starts to doze off. And that's when things take a dark turn: by the end of the session, Olga is found strangled on his couch...
I've always been fascinated by the idea of therapists as ordinary people with their own fears and weaknesses. In real life, they often have impenetrable facades and who knows what's really going on in their heads.
I have to say, the movie really lets you see behind the mask of the doctor, and it's even more interesting to watch when they get into trouble. It's also fascinating to see how they, as a psychologist, will get out of the situation with the murder that happened right under their nose.
Who killed Laura P Olga Kubler?
But, surprisingly, the film reminds me of Twin Peaks in terms of the detective aspect. The combination of suspense and humor, the charismatic characters connected in strange ways and with plenty of secrets, the switching between storylines and mixing in flashbacks and dreams, and the theme of a woman in trouble and women in general – it's all there in the series and exactly the same in Benex's film.
I'd say it's even more – although the film is full of different intrigues, it's clear from the start who the killer is, and the details of the story unfold throughout the movie. And it's the murder that drives the plot forward. If Laura had lived, this film wouldn't have been made – just like Twin Peaks.
There's also a detective-slash-investigator, kind of, and that's the main character, Michel Duran.
The only difference is that Duran becomes a suspect in the story and has to cover his tracks, while also figuring out the mystery and himself at the same time.
One thing that struck me about Benex's approach is how different it is from Lynch's. Lynch was all about trusting your subconscious and going with the flow, without expecting that every mystery has a clear answer.
xa0
The concept of 'Fatal Transfer' is all about excavating and burying your own psychological baggage.
Everyone in the film is doing this, and the main character is basically an expert at digging up people's hidden desires and fears.
That's why people come to him to unload the pent-up frustration and anger they have to keep bottled up in society. And Michelle does this 'excavation' by asking probing questions.
But to avoid getting overwhelmed by other people's suffering, Michelle takes care to refer to a more experienced therapist, and there she digs herself out from under other people's problems and does a bit of excavation of her own – she's in supervision.
xa0
I've gotta say, the only person who's not into this whole excavation thing is Elane, Michel's new girlfriend. She's not all about digging deep, but more about spilling her thoughts onto canvases – a totally different approach.
I think that's why they clicked: when your job is all about getting into someone's head, you want to take a break from that in your personal life. As an artist, Elane doesn't try to find the perfect words for things, but she's great at having a clear conversation without all the analysis and jargon.
xa0
_____________________________________________________
xa0
Symbolism, themes.
xa0
Mortel Transfer is a film that's ridiculously easy to follow, no need to overthink it and try to figure out what the author meant. The symbolism is right there in front of you, even if you're not a seasoned viewer.
I've mentioned the metaphorical meaning of excavation before, but here we get both literal and figurative meanings. Michel's 'digging' into people's minds, letting them confront their painful thoughts, and then he literally has to deal with a dead body)
xa0
The corpse is a shameful problem people want to keep hidden and quietly get rid of. It's hilarious to see how during a session, she freaks Michel out, but the patient doesn't even notice) There are a few scenes with similar meaning, but this one is the most striking. And the funniest)
I've noticed that the patient doesn't seem to see the 'problems' because a lot of what's going on inside is often invisible. The way the hand pops out from under the couch is a clever representation of that. During the session, Michelle is so focused on his own tension that he can't concentrate on the work at hand.
It's probably what a therapist looks like when they're not doing their job properly and are violating professional ethics.
Michelle is so caught up in Olga's case that he makes a few critical mistakes, including giving false testimony to the police. Or at least, he thinks he should have referred Olga to another doctor by now, but he doesn't.
It's interesting that the 'problem' turns out to be a woman. From a creative perspective, it makes sense – there are femme fatales, but not male equivalents.
From a psychoanalytic perspective, I see this as the idea that a woman, whether alive or dead, is always a problem for a man.
Olga is a perceptive woman who's got the therapist stumped, and her husband's aggression only seems to amuse her.
I've seen characters like Olga before – she's the ultimate emotional manipulator, always digging up people's deepest fears and anxieties just to get a rise out of them. In a way, Olga represents how men often view women: living, breathing problems that are somehow less of a hassle when they're dead.
The addition of the necrophile and his blow-up doll on the graveyard set is a pretty clear indication of what men often crave but are too afraid to admit to themselves.
Michele Duran, on the other hand, is a refreshing exception to the rule.
xa0
Psychological issues have a way of piling up over time. They snowball, and our memories start to blur the lines between reality and fantasy. And the worst part is, as long as there's at least one issue holding you back from living your life, it'll be there to haunt you – in every glance, every innocent comment, and every mundane situation.
After finding the body, Michele's interactions with others are laced with paranoia and distrust. And the raw, unflinching portrayal of his inner turmoil is downright unsettling.
xa0
I've got to say, it's not worth dragging out the process of getting rid of them. So, Michelle grabs the dead body of Olga and tosses it into the trunk of the car the first chance she gets.
xa0
Getting rid of the mental block with the childhood memories is similar. After someone ripped the head off her stuffed giraffe, Michelle basically buries the toy in the ground.
xa0xa0It's only when she digs it up that she's able to figure out what the toy looked like and what color it was.
xa0
==========================================
xa0
Key Features
xa0
Mortal Transfer is definitely in my top 5 favorite movies. It's a great film because it's complex enough to keep you engaged, but not so complex that you can't enjoy it while munching on popcorn. At the same time, it's smart and interesting, without any cringeworthy toilet humor. Although, there are some low-brow jokes, they fit with the rest of the film.
xa0
I wouldn't say that the film has any standout, memorable visual characteristics. Although, the views of France are always beautiful, and the cemeteries are immaculately kept:
xa0xa0The cinematography is good, but it doesn't blow me away. Especially after I noticed a continuity error – someone with a microphone walked backwards in front of the main character:
Around 1:17:42I've got to say, the editor did a fantastic job. The surreal scenes with rapid-fire cuts looked like acid-trip music videos and perfectly captured the story's essence.
I loved how they used double exposure – the sleeping character hearing sounds from the real world through their dreams was a stroke of genius.
Computer graphics aren't really my thing, but they're consistent throughout the film.
xa0
The script, episode composition, humor, and that quintessential French flair really won me over.
The movie clocks in at around 2 hours – standard fare for me, but some folks might find it a bit long. The action keeps you hooked till the very end, and I found myself wondering what would happen next and how it would all wrap up. Some of the lines, like the therapist's bit about listening to people's inner jungles, really made me think.
I was impressed by how they handled Olga's kleptomania – we're shown the process of her subtle thievery, and the actress nailed it.
I've got to say, the acting is top-notch. It's one of those cases where you completely get sucked into the atmosphere, and the reactions of the characters feel so natural that you don't even want to analyze it.
xa0
Music-wise, I'd give it 9 out of 10. The opening melody was a bit of a downer, but overall, it's great. I loved how the staccato sounds of the violin really drive home the stress Michel's under when he's messing with the corpse.
xa0
That necrophile scene is one of my favorites, and it's all because of the music. The scene where he's getting it on with a gaudily-painted doll amidst the gothic tombstones is a total departure from the norm, and the dull, repetitive beat just adds to the effect.
xa0
=========================================
xa0
My Takeaways
Despite its flaws, the film is a real gem. The director's done an amazing job of laying out the material. It's like he's been to therapy and come out with a clear head, because the logic of the plot is just spot-on.